Home Division of Property Who Keeps the Ring? Evelyn Lozada says ‘tough luck’ after engagement to Carl Crawford

Who Keeps the Ring? Evelyn Lozada says ‘tough luck’ after engagement to Carl Crawford


Evelyn Lozada called off her engagement to Carl Crawford for a wedding that was set to take place 3 weeks ago. She stated that she had doubts as to her fiance’s fidelity. The television personality is making headlines again for keeping the 14.5 carat ring worth a whopping $1.4 million.

In California, an engagement ring is considered a conditional gift – you get ownership of the ring on the condition that you get married. If that condition is not satisfied, then there is a legal obligation to return the ring. In Ontario however, the law is a little grayer.

There is no hard and fast rule in Ontario law when it comes to the treatment of engagement rings. Courts will tend to look at who ended the relationship. If a woman has accepted the ring and then refused to fulfill the commitment to marry, courts have ordered the return of the ring. However, where a man proposes and then changes his mind, he generally will not get the ring back after reneging on his promise of marriage. There are however cases where the court has indicated that an engagement ring is a gift like any other in the eyes of the law, and therefore once it is given, the giftor cannot demand its return. This seems more in line with the thinking of Ms. Lozada.

Andrew Feldstein The Feldstein Family Law Group (FFLG) is one the largest family law firms that practices Family Law exclusively in Greater Toronto, with 10 lawyers and counting. The boutique law firm has won the Top Choice Award for Family Law™ in Toronto for the past eleven years (2007 to 2017 inclusive). Managing Partner Andrew Feldstein has been practicing family law for more than 20 years and frequently comments on Family Law issues through the media. The Feldstein Family Law Group offers vast written, video, and media resources on its website to those who find that they need to end their relationship.